Pope and Young is only for "Record" animals....has nothing to do with managing the herd for acceptable levels... Ie, does, young bucks, etc.
Hunting is what you make it. If you only want trophy animals, that are regarded by certain people based on being taken by certain rules, then so be it.
If you hunt for the enjoyment, meat, etc, and aren't in it for the horn porn.... that road is always open as well.