TreeStandBowHunter Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Answer this. Why are we messing with Iran again. Is GW trying to repeat Iraq???...but yet we have Korea flat out telling us they have/or are making nukes? Whats the deal here. GW might want to take a look at the Military situation before he makes any moves. JMO Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Norm Sauceman Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS GW is not the only one who is messing with Iran...We are not the only ones dealing with North Korea either (6 nations I believe right now including Japan and China) Iran is a state that harbours Terrorists and terrorists are a direct threat to the US.. North Korea is a more direct threat to Japan and China than to us... This is only my opinion though.. Iran has so many sanctions against them it is not funny and we are working to inpose many more... but I would not rule out military action if needed... I know... I get hammered with it all the time... WELL THEN MR. SMARTY.. LET'S SEND YOUR SON THERE THEN,... Then my answer is... OK.. but I would like the opportunity first to go, but seeing as I could not, if my son needed to go, then that would be how it was... We can not sit around and be complacent when these radicals find new and more devistating means of killing Democracies... I don;t think it would be the same as I feel about going into Afghanistan and Iraq, it would be a bit different circumsatnces as far as I am concerned..why, you ask?? I felt Afghanistan was a direct response to 9/11.. I felt, although it was not stressed as much as WMD's, that Saddam and his radicals were murdering thousands upon thousands of the Iraqis with no reguard for suffering or anything.. He needed to be stopped. Just as Hitler needed to be stopped.. Iran and North Korea are different.. they are bullies upon the whole world in they flaunt nuclear power and intent as a tool to get financial and other means of support from the other countries of the world..then when they need more..they do it all over again. This has been going on with NK for as long as this dictator has been in power. It has been on and off in Iran with the changing of the latest faction to take over the country. This is not nor should be construed as FACT.. This is the way old Norm sees it... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TreeStandBowHunter Posted February 12, 2005 Author Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS Ya know Norm, thats probably the best answer I will receive on this too. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
fisherguy Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS I think the biggest difference between Iran and Iraq is that the citizens of Iran as a whole are more fanatical and do not want to be "liberated". Afghanistan went fairly well, Iraq...well it is slowly getting there, Iran i think would be complete disaster. Why? 1. Your military is worn out. 2. Public suport: I really doubt there would be much of that for an invasion of Iran(either within the States or outside). 3. It would even further polarize the middle east against the west and lead to more Anti-americanism there which would in turn lead to more danger of terrorism. What should be done...i really don't know. Obviously something, but i do not think war is the way to go. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GWSmith Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS [ QUOTE ] Answer this. Why are we messing with Iran again. Is GW trying to repeat Iraq???...but yet we have Korea flat out telling us they have/or are making nukes? Whats the deal here. GW might want to take a look at the Military situation before he makes any moves. JMO [/ QUOTE ] TSBH...Dude....Please leave me out of this...LOL I'm still trying to remember what day is my wifes birthday I'm in enough trouble Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
wtnhunt Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS Great response Norm. Pretty well agree with everything Norm has to say here. Hope military action is not needed in either place. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
James7xChamp3 Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS Why do we as Citizens think we know everything about World affairs because of what we read in the papers and hear on the news????? If we all know what our President and our Military leaders knows, I think we would be in big trouble! I am confident that Mr. Bush among others has had to bite their lips and just shake their heads of what has been said and written the last 4 years. We know what THEY want us to know which isn't much. In reality we know very little about a lot of things. I guess it's fun and exciting to pretend we do though. It sure puts lots of money in the Media folks pockets! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TreeStandBowHunter Posted February 12, 2005 Author Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS [ QUOTE ] Why do we as Citizens think we know everything about World affairs because of what we read in the papers and hear on the news????? If we all know what our President and our Military leaders knows, I think we would be in big trouble! I am confident that Mr. Bush among others has had to bite their lips and just shake their heads of what has been said and written the last 4 years. We know what THEY want us to know which isn't much. In reality we know very little about a lot of things. I guess it's fun and exciting to pretend we do though. It sure puts lots of money in the Media folks pockets! [/ QUOTE ] Yeah, your right. What would I know or even have the right to know or think. I mean it isin't like I been to Iraq and been shot at by the little arabs or anything right? I mean it isin't like I am part of this Global War On Terror or anything right? I am just a normal everyday citizen? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
carbonhunter Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS [ QUOTE ] [ QUOTE ] Why do we as Citizens think we know everything about World affairs because of what we read in the papers and hear on the news????? If we all know what our President and our Military leaders knows, I think we would be in big trouble! I am confident that Mr. Bush among others has had to bite their lips and just shake their heads of what has been said and written the last 4 years. We know what THEY want us to know which isn't much. In reality we know very little about a lot of things. I guess it's fun and exciting to pretend we do though. It sure puts lots of money in the Media folks pockets! [/ QUOTE ] Yeah, your right. What would I know or even have the right to know or think. I mean it isin't like I been to Iraq and been shot at by the little arabs or anything right? I mean it isin't like I am part of this Global War On Terror or anything right? I am just a normal everyday citizen? [/ QUOTE ] Ahh Mike...i was going to save you the time but ya beat me to it. I dont know what to say about Iran. Bush has to know that we cant do anything right now.....we are streatched way to thin. I'm not so worried about Iran as I'am about NK, Hussain was an Insain freak....but a dumb insain freak. NK has a very very smart insain freak, there news release this week couldnt have been timed better. IMO Bush is putting his foot in his mouth right now. Kinda like a big hold'em game NK keeps trying to force the hand. We have kinda set the table for him though. First we label them in the axis of evil, along with Iraq. We go into Iraq and now Kim can claim self defense. Im not trying to get into the past but this is a problem with starting this Pre-emptive strike stuff. That said I think Bush is smart enough to know that we wood have a long up hill struggle in NK without a pretty good aliance. I also think NK can be contained and strangled. He dosnt have crap for money a fight on his soil would be tough, but if you force them to come out than they can be beat. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TreeStandBowHunter Posted February 12, 2005 Author Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS [ QUOTE ] Why do we as Citizens think we know everything about World affairs because of what we read in the papers and hear on the news????? If we all know what our President and our Military leaders knows, I think we would be in big trouble! I am confident that Mr. Bush among others has had to bite their lips and just shake their heads of what has been said and written the last 4 years. We know what THEY want us to know which isn't much. In reality we know very little about a lot of things. I guess it's fun and exciting to pretend we do though. It sure puts lots of money in the Media folks pockets! [/ QUOTE ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gator Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS Norm gave a pretty good answer. here is my take on N Korea. There are WAYYYYY to many countries in that area that do NOT want N Korea to possess nuclear weapons. I think that we will "use" those countries in an effort to get N Korea to "tame down" their Nuclear program. Every stinking year N Korea does SOMETHING like this in an attempt to get outside help in one form or another, almost like blackmailing the rest of the world. Iran, I don't know what to think of them. Personally we need to finish what has been started in Afghanistan and Iraq and "rebuild" our military before even messing with them. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
OJR Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS I agree with Gator in regards to NK! They have been pulling this crap since the Korean war, so it is nothing new. What is new is they now have the nuclear bombs. The big and I mean BIG thing is that China and Japan are really keeping a very close watch on them. China didn't always do this. In fact, China armed and helped them during the Korean war! Different time and situation now. In regards to Iran, I really believe that Israel is going to do something about them. You must remember, the people want to get rid of the hard line religious rulers but don't dare to do anything because they will end up in prison or worse. Iran is going to be in real trouble once Iraq settles down a bit! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
horst Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS Ok but heres the question, do we have the manpower right now to even be looking at Iran?TSBH knows more about this then I do but I was under the impression were already stretching ourselves pretty thin.There might be a time to go into Iran but we aint dumb enough to try it this soon are we?Maybe Im wrong, weve got everything over there now, no sense hauling it all back home just to take it back over Im only half joking, maybe their thinking the same thing in the white house Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
popgun Posted February 12, 2005 Report Share Posted February 12, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS Just say I had a lot of coyotes killing the deer in my friends hunting area. So I was hunting coyotes on their turf and had already killed quite a few, running low on ammo, and wanted to go back to the truck and call off the rest of the evenings hunt. I only have 2 shells left but there are still a lot of coyotes following me to the truck. I may not be able to wipe them out if they were all to attack me at once, but I sure would be watching them closely on my way out of the woods. This is sort of how I look at Iraq, and it's neighbor Iran. Maybe this isn't such a good example but.................. ,,,,,popgun Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Strut_Buster Posted February 13, 2005 Report Share Posted February 13, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS N.Korea can have all the nukes they want for self defense. Cause if they cause a ruckus over there they will have China, japan, and The south to answer to. I say we just pull our Troops and Flyers out and move them into afganistan and Iraq. That is were the worlds hotspot is now, no longer korea. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
James7xChamp3 Posted February 13, 2005 Report Share Posted February 13, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS [ QUOTE ] [ QUOTE ] Why do we as Citizens think we know everything about World affairs because of what we read in the papers and hear on the news????? If we all know what our President and our Military leaders knows, I think we would be in big trouble! I am confident that Mr. Bush among others has had to bite their lips and just shake their heads of what has been said and written the last 4 years. We know what THEY want us to know which isn't much. In reality we know very little about a lot of things. I guess it's fun and exciting to pretend we do though. It sure puts lots of money in the Media folks pockets! [/ QUOTE ] Yeah, your right. What would I know or even have the right to know or think. I mean it isin't like I been to Iraq and been shot at by the little arabs or anything right? I mean it isin't like I am part of this Global War On Terror or anything right? I am just a normal everyday citizen? [/ QUOTE ] Sorry if I offended you , I was referring to regular Citizens. You will find no one more appreciative and respectful towards what you and the rest of the troops do and have done for our Country than myself. You are all in my prayers everyday! I listen to people at work everyyday putting down GW and the military in general. I read it in the papers and I hear it on the news. People who have no military experience at all telling the world how bad prisoners of war are treated and what "methods" should be used to gain information from terrorists and how inhumane the military's tactics are for trying to extract information from them, War sucks, but it is why we are as free as we are. I just meant that we need to trust you and the rest of the military (including GW) in this war on terrorism. Questioning military tactics should be left to you and others who are actually involved. The rest of us can have opinions, but that's all they are as we haven't "been there and done that" and can only base our thoughts on what we read and hear. I sleep soundly at night because of you and the rest of our troops and I ask God every night to keep you safe and bring you home soon to your families and loved ones. Again, I'm sorry my post came across as offensive and a sincere thanks for all you do for this great country! As part of the military, YOUR thoughts and opinions are what we should listen to. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TreeStandBowHunter Posted February 13, 2005 Author Report Share Posted February 13, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS OK, Horst to answer your question...YES. I can tell you first hand that we are already stretched to the limit. I don't know about the Army because they are about agillzillion times larger than us but as far as the Marines go, we are about 1 man deep in units right now. I think the people in the rear(states) are working harder than the Marines over in Iraq and Afghan right now. I mean I know when I was in Iraq, we spent more down time fooling around than going out and getting shot at. For some reason, this world wants the Marines to handle all the hotspots Remember what Reagan said "Some people go through an entire lifetime wondering if they made a difference to this world....The Marines don't have that problem". Or this is a better one "The US doesn't need the Marine Corps, They want a Marine Corps". What I am saying is that plays a big part on our operations. They are throwing Marines in certain missions that they usually do not do because they want the mission accomplished. Hey not knocking the Army or anything but look at Falujjua(sp)...no one else could handle it so they through us in there. That type of stuff is hurting the Marine Corps mission right now. We are supposed to be deployed world wide ie MEU's and MSSG's but right now, we are confined to Iraq and it is hurting our mission. We don't need another war right now. Trust me man, our gear and personnel are so broken down right now it isin't even funny. Not enough to jepordize the mission but you know what I am getting at right? I didn't agree with Iraq and never will. I don't care what the excuse is today that they come up with but what I do know is the real reason that we went to war with Iraq was because they said that they had WMD's. Today they are saying that they did not. There is no getting around that. Our job in Afghanistan is not even done yet. The real bad guy is out there yet. Iraq was no threat to us..maybe other countries but not to us. HOWEVER, I always supported Bush and always will and I think he is the right man for the job as far as the War on Terror goes. His administation failed him the last term. I don't blame Bush at all...I blame his administration for the false information. Bush was only acting on his intell that he received from HIS administration. I will say that I am surprised that Rumsfield is still in there Plain and simple(after all this blabbing) If he says we are going to Iran or Korea, than I am there. However, I think if Bush attacks Iran, it will cause a catashtrophie(sp). Not necessary from Iran but in General. I was just wonder what all yalls opinion was on this hot topic this week in the news. But hey, what the heck do I know right Holy cow my signature is big...I guess I need to downsize it huh Buckee. I'll get around to it later and fix it Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TreeStandBowHunter Posted February 13, 2005 Author Report Share Posted February 13, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS [ QUOTE ] [ QUOTE ] [ QUOTE ] Why do we as Citizens think we know everything about World affairs because of what we read in the papers and hear on the news????? If we all know what our President and our Military leaders knows, I think we would be in big trouble! I am confident that Mr. Bush among others has had to bite their lips and just shake their heads of what has been said and written the last 4 years. We know what THEY want us to know which isn't much. In reality we know very little about a lot of things. I guess it's fun and exciting to pretend we do though. It sure puts lots of money in the Media folks pockets! [/ QUOTE ] Yeah, your right. What would I know or even have the right to know or think. I mean it isin't like I been to Iraq and been shot at by the little arabs or anything right? I mean it isin't like I am part of this Global War On Terror or anything right? I am just a normal everyday citizen? [/ QUOTE ] Sorry if I offended you , I was referring to regular Citizens. You will find no one more appreciative and respectful towards what you and the rest of the troops do and have done for our Country than myself. You are all in my prayers everyday! I listen to people at work everyyday putting down GW and the military in general. I read it in the papers and I hear it on the news. People who have no military experience at all telling the world how bad prisoners of war are treated and what "methods" should be used to gain information from terrorists and how inhumane the military's tactics are for trying to extract information from them, War sucks, but it is why we are as free as we are. I just meant that we need to trust you and the rest of the military (including GW) in this war on terrorism. Questioning military tactics should be left to you and others who are actually involved. The rest of us can have opinions, but that's all they are as we haven't "been there and done that" and can only base our thoughts on what we read and hear. I sleep soundly at night because of you and the rest of our troops and I ask God every night to keep you safe and bring you home soon to your families and loved ones. Again, I'm sorry my post came across as offensive and a sincere thanks for all you do for this great country! As part of the military, YOUR thoughts and opinions are what we should listen to. [/ QUOTE ] All yeah, I forgot about you. Don't worry about me man, I'm not mad. I just jump on things quick thats all. No offense taken. But you still get one of these though Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
slugshooter Posted February 14, 2005 Report Share Posted February 14, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS [ QUOTE ] I will say that I am surprised that Rumsfield is still in there [/ QUOTE ] I am surprised myelf Mike. I read about 2 weeks ago that supposedly Rumsfeld submitted his resignation to Bush during the Abu Ghraib scandal and Bush would not accept it. So basically, IMHO, Rumsfeld was trying to own up to his mistakes and Bush condoned them by not accepting his resignation, thats my feelings on it anyway. Mike, remember when I first started coming in here and we basically agreed on a statement I made that " in international politics and war, there is no room for assumption and accusations." And that is just as true to me as it was back when I first typed it. Yes, it was the administration that failed him and provided the faulty intelligence, but when you are threatening invasion, there needs to be absolute, undeniable proof, and sadly, there wasn't. I believe they should all be held accountable, at least the ones responsible for selling the war. General Shinsecki warned Donald Rumsfeld that "hundreds of thousands" of troops would be needed to stabilize Iraq not the 100,000 planned, well, Shinsecki was right, our military is stretched thin and Iraq is not exactly stable is it. Shinsecki didn't stay as Army Chief of Staff much longer after that. This administration has proven over and over that they will not tolerate dissent and questioning of policies, like Bush told the world, you are either with us or with the terrorists, well, it's not much different within his administration I suspect. What does Rumsfeld know about the military, he never served, he has pushed pencils all his life, Rumsfelds problem is he thinks he knows more than the grunts and officers who are actually in the military and know whats going on and know what they are capable. " You go to war with the Army you have, not the Army you want." A completely rude, thoughtless and ignorant statement, at least now that families who have given the ultimate sacrifice by losing a son or daughter over there in Iraq will now have a handsigned letter from him expressing his condolences that their son/daughter was killed in action instead of those autopen letters he was shilling out. I think that was one of the worst things I had heard him doing, you know, it may not make up for the loss, but how do those families feel to get a letter "supposedly" from the Secretary of Defense expressing his condolences that never even crossed his desk and most likely didn't even know what it said. I have absolutely no respect for the man. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Norm Sauceman Posted February 14, 2005 Report Share Posted February 14, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS I am suprised to see Rumsfeld still there too... Heck, I want someone in there that will get the job done and I mean NOW!!!!! Sweep it up and throw it away!!!!!! No more messing around... Unconventional warefare just like the beginning of Afghanistan... Lay 'em out!!!!! Read "The Hunt for Bin Laden"... It is good stuff but it will make you mad when politics gets involved in war... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ParrotHead Posted February 14, 2005 Report Share Posted February 14, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS Why are we not messing with Korea? Because those little jokers have been wanting to detanate a nuke for years now and are just looking for the first suspect. Those little idiots over there are suicidal - have nothing to live for thus all the more reason to reek havic amoung those that do. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
stevebeilgard Posted February 14, 2005 Report Share Posted February 14, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS norm had a great answer. remember, we are a 100% volunteer army. so what's the beef? as for north korea, i'm dunbfounded that anyone actually believes them... but wait! let's see... clinton administration gave the chinese & korean the technology. albright stated that the world would be safer if more countries had nuke technology. so, what are we so afraid of? (except that she was as dumb as a fencepost!) look, who actually believes that they 1) actually have a bomb (no tests yet, remember) and 2) could actually get them here. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
slugshooter Posted February 14, 2005 Report Share Posted February 14, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS Yep, Madelyn Albright was as dumb as a fencepost, can you say anything without making yourself sound like a child, cause I am pretty sure she can take you down in a battle of wits any day. As far as people in politics being dumb, noone gets to the upper echelon of international politics by being "dumb" As far as nukes, I believe they have them, why couldn't they, even if they did hardly anyone would know cause the country is so secretive. As far as Iran, they probably have them, Russia says they are going to build the biggest, there are plenty of countries out there that were bigger threats than Saddam Hussein and Iraq, so why are we there, there are worse dictators than Hussein. Why haven't we deposed Castro yet, he's been around longer and been denying basic human rights longer than any of them. I wouldn't mind being able to get some real Cuban cigars legally. One more question, if you are a member of the Team Realtree Pro Staff like your bio says, why isn't your picture on the pro staff page Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
slugshooter Posted February 14, 2005 Report Share Posted February 14, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS [ QUOTE ] look, who actually believes that they 1) actually have a bomb (no tests yet, remember) and 2) could actually get them here. [/ QUOTE ] Well, GW believed that Iraq had WMD's even though there had been no record of one being used since before 1991, plus, he believed that Iraq was pursuing the manufacture of a Nuclear weapon, which, even the Bush Admin has admitted was false, or a lie, however you want to take it. And who says it has to be tested for it to be there, what happened to the argument of a pre-emptive strike, that was the basis for going into Iraq wasn't it? We have to get them before they get us? That may work in war games, but when real people die and real bombs go off, there can be no assumption and there must be undeniable fact, unfortunately, we didn't have that, and half the world despises us now. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Norm Sauceman Posted February 14, 2005 Report Share Posted February 14, 2005 Re: OK ALL YOU POLITICAL KNOW IT ALLS S;ug, I have to disagree with you on the above post a little. There were a couple of instances where a car bomb was a dud and did not go off and when the bomb squad got there they found serin powder in the caps and in the casing. They said it was enough to poison a whole city block if it would have gone off. Now, I know it was not a stockpile and all, but I do believe it was there. It may have also been old, but when I was watching the report, they said had it ignighted, it would most likely have been lethal for some. I am just wondering how much of this is still hidden in Iraq and abroad. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.