Like others have said the fake cutaways definitely turn me, and the TV, off. We know the camera is not outside the ground blind and we're not watching the actual drawing and shot of the bow...when the deer is @ 15 yds. looking in your direction. Another definite dislike is the constant bickering/jousting between co-hosts/spouses.
Likes are great camera footage(heartland bowhunter) and family interaction(family traditions w/haley heath). With real emotion(fred eichler).
Involving the viewer by having them send in their name to be selected for a future hunt, in their area, on each show would probably never happen but it would be very interesting to watch how those shows turned out!