Re: Theres no reason not to manage!!!!!!!
There is no doubt that under the right conditions QDM works great,but much like wtnhunt,our conditions are far from ideal.About 4 years ago I decided to not shoot 1 1/2 old bucks any more,and have only killed two bucks since, including this year.It's something I have no problem dealing with as long as I put some doe meat in the freezer.On one property I hunt me and my cousin are the only ones with permission, and he's been using the same rule as me for 2 1/2 and up.Since we've been doing this I haven't seen any increase in the number of big bucks at all.We don't really do this really for management,but because we like to shoot a little bigger deer.
We have a few things going against us.
#1-we don't own the property, and the owners don't want us to put food plots in...they keep the property a certain way and that's how they like it.No biggy,I'm just happy to have a place to hunt.
#2-Our properties are small.One is 30 acres,and the other is about 100,and both have heavy hunting pressure on surrounding properties,especially during gun season.
If I had my own property,and it was relatively large I would absolutely strictly manage it,but odds are it will never happen,so for the moment the 1 1/2 olds get a free pass till next year.