Another nope here. I just shake my head every time I hear this. I guess when this theory came up, no one really aged the deer, or it started somewhere in deer camp when someone shot a spike and his buddies gave him crap for it so he said it. Then his buddies, being drunk of course, were like, you know what? That makes alot of sense, I think. Then they shot a spike and told their other buddies and so on.